Discuss the effectiveness of supply-side policies in delivering growth that is both inclusive and sustainable, considering the events mentioned.
The year 2020 was marked by extreme events. International travel came to a near standstill, oil prices experienced dramatic swings, and trade in medical supplies surged. Consumer spending shifted away from services towards goods, while household savings soared as people remained at home during the global lockdown. However, many of the factors behind persistent external imbalances existed even before the pandemic—such as fiscal imbalances, structural issues, and competitiveness-related distortions.
b. Discuss the effectiveness of supply-side policies in delivering growth that is both inclusive and sustainable, considering the events mentioned. [15]
Introduction
The year 2020 brought with it a range of economic disruptions—from the collapse of international travel and dramatic swings in oil prices, to the surge in demand for medical supplies and a shift in consumer spending patterns. While these changes were prompted by the COVID-19 pandemic, many of the underlying structural problems—such as fiscal imbalances, income inequality, and environmental degradation—predated the crisis. In this context, supply-side policies, which aim to enhance the productive capacity of the economy, can play a crucial role in achieving growth that is both inclusive (benefiting all segments of society) and sustainable (environmentally and fiscally viable over the long term). However, the effectiveness of such policies depends on their design, implementation, and the economic environment in which they operate.
Education and retraining to achieve inclusive growth
One key avenue for inclusive growth is through education and retraining, particularly for low-income groups and displaced workers. By investing in human capital, the government can help equip workers with the skills needed for higher-value jobs in a rapidly changing economy.
When governments subsidise training programmes or increase access to education, this can raise the productivity of lower-income workers. An increase in productivity raises the marginal revenue product of labour, allowing workers to command higher wages. This contributes to a narrowing of the income gap, thereby promoting greater equity. At the macroeconomic level, a more skilled workforce expands the economy’s productive capacity, shifting the Long-Run Aggregate Supply (LRAS) curve to the right, enabling higher real national income (NY) without triggering inflation.
A relevant real-world example is Singapore’s Tech Immersion and Placement Programme (TIPP), run by the Infocomm Media Development Authority (IMDA), which offers up to 70% subsidy for mid-career individuals to be trained in digital skills. A notable case involved a 53-year-old taxi driver who was successfully retrained to become a full-stack developer within 9 months—a striking example of how targeted retraining can lead to upward mobility and inclusion.
However, despite such success stories, several challenges remain. First, behavioural and attitudinal barriers—particularly among older workers—can reduce participation rates in such programmes. Many may be reluctant to leave their familiar roles or lack confidence in their ability to learn new skills, making widespread effectiveness difficult to achieve.
Second, the government may struggle to identify which sectors or skills should be prioritised. If funding is directed towards courses that are poorly designed or misaligned with market demand, there may be wastage of public funds with little to show in terms of employability or productivity gains.
Third, such policies take time to yield results, especially in sectors where skill accumulation and credentialing are slow. During a crisis like a pandemic, the benefits of long-term human capital investments may not arrive quickly enough to offset immediate job losses.
Finally, the opportunity cost of retraining can be high. Workers may lose income while undergoing training, and employers may be reluctant to release staff for extended periods, especially in small firms with tight labour constraints. This is further compounded by fiscal constraints—governments already running budget deficits due to pandemic-related stimulus may find it difficult to sustainably fund large-scale training programmes.
Encouraging investment in green technology to achieve sustainable growth
Another major supply-side policy that contributes to sustainable growth is the provision of grants and subsidies for firms investing in green technology. This aligns growth with long-term environmental goals by encouraging the private sector to shift towards cleaner, more energy-efficient production.
By offering financial incentives, governments can nudge firms to switch from fossil fuels to renewable energy, adopt energy-efficient technologies, or invest in research and development (R&D) for low-carbon solutions. These investments raise the capital productivity of firms, increasing the economy’s potential output, which manifests as a rightward shift of the LRAS curve. Simultaneously, such policies help reduce negative externalities such as air and water pollution, leading to improved environmental quality—a critical dimension of sustainability.
Moreover, supporting green innovation can have positive spillover effects. As firms develop new green technologies, these can be adopted across the economy, lowering the overall carbon footprint and contributing to global efforts against climate change.
However, there are limitations and challenges to this approach. First, when oil prices are low—as they were for much of 2020—firms may find it cheaper and more profitable to continue using conventional energy sources. As profit-maximisation is a dominant objective in the private sector, low oil prices can reduce the incentive to invest in cleaner technologies, even if long-term benefits exist.
Additionally, green subsidies can be expensive to maintain, especially in fiscally constrained environments. The opportunity cost of using limited public funds to subsidise green projects must be considered, particularly if such subsidies are captured by large firms with minimal environmental impact or if they crowd out more cost-effective environmental measures.
Furthermore, the impact of green investments on employment and inclusiveness is not always straightforward. For example, while new jobs may be created in the green sector, workers in traditional industries such as oil refining or manufacturing may be displaced. If not accompanied by effective retraining schemes, this could worsen income inequality, even as the economy becomes greener.
Conclusion
Supply-side policies have the potential to support both inclusive and sustainable economic growth, especially in a post-pandemic world where structural weaknesses have been further exposed. Initiatives such as education and retraining can help close the income gap and enhance productivity, while green subsidies can promote environmental sustainability alongside economic expansion.
However, the effectiveness of such policies depends heavily on context and execution. Fiscal constraints, behavioural barriers, time lags, and misaligned incentives can all reduce the impact of these policies. Policymakers must therefore adopt a holistic and adaptive approach, combining supply-side reforms with demand management, labour market policies, and international cooperation to ensure that growth benefits all segments of society without compromising the needs of future generations.
🏁 J2 Last Lap — Your Final Push to A Level Success
Found this essay helpful? Now it’s time to learn how to write one like it — in the exam, under pressure, with confidence.
At Economics at Tuitiongenius (ETG) — Singapore’s most trusted economics tuition centre — we go beyond content delivery. Led by Mr Eugene Toh, one of Singapore’s most experienced economics tutors, we help students structure, evaluate, and write their way to consistent L3s.
🚀 Introducing the JC2 Last Lap Programme
This is your all-in-one H2 economics tuition system — designed to help you finish strong, with clear guidance, high-impact resources, and weekly momentum.
✅ What’s Included:
61 Recorded JC2 Lessons — On-demand access for deep revision anytime
Weekly Live Classes — Join onsite (4 locations) or via Zoom
11 Included Crashcourses — Drills for essays, CSQs, content review, evaluation, and exam planning
Printed Materials Delivered — Textbooks, diagrams, essay frameworks, summaries
1-on-1 Consults with Mr Toh — Personalised coaching when it matters most
Weekly Homework + Feedback — Real improvement, not blind drilling
💬 “I scored an E for MYEs… and an A for the A Levels — because of ETG.”
– Wing Ter Tan, Class of 2023
💡 Perfect For:
JC2 students aiming to break through the B barrier
Anyone struggling with evaluation, exam planning, or CSQs
Students searching for economics tuition Singapore that offers structure, feedback, and real results
🔗 Register now at tuitiongenius.com/lastlap
📲 Or WhatsApp us at 8168 3986 — we’ll guide you to your best term yet
The A is within reach. With ETG, the plan is already written — let’s follow it together.