Discuss the shortcomings of using these statistics to assess changes in Singapore’s standard of living in 2017 and for cross-country comparisons.
In 2017, Singapore's real GDP, based on 2010 prices, expanded by 3.6%, while the total population grew marginally by 0.1%. Consumer price index inflation was recorded at 0.6%, and the overall unemployment rate was 3.1%
b. Discuss the shortcomings of using these statistics to assess changes in Singapore’s standard of living in 2017 and for cross-country comparisons. [15]
Introduction
In assessing changes in the standard of living (SOL) in Singapore in 2017 and comparing it with other countries, various economic indicators such as GDP growth, inflation, and unemployment rates provide useful insights. However, these statistics also have significant limitations. The standard of living encompasses both material well-being, measured by income levels and access to goods and services, as well as non-material aspects such as quality of life, environmental conditions, and overall social well-being. While economic indicators may offer a broad overview, they often fail to capture the nuances of income distribution, purchasing power, and non-material factors that influence the actual living conditions of individuals within a country. Moreover, when making international comparisons, differences in data accuracy, exchange rate fluctuations, and variations in cost of living further complicate a meaningful assessment.
Shortcomings for comparing between 2017 and before
One major limitation of using GDP per capita to assess changes in the standard of living within Singapore in 2017 is that it does not account for income inequality. GDP per capita represents an average measure of income, which can be misleading in a society where income distribution is highly uneven. A rise in GDP per capita does not necessarily imply an improvement in the standard of living for the majority of the population if income gains are concentrated among the wealthy. In such cases, median wages might provide a more accurate representation of how the typical citizen is faring economically.
Furthermore, GDP per capita fails to capture non-material aspects of the standard of living. While it provides insight into material well-being, it does not account for factors such as work-life balance, environmental quality, healthcare accessibility, and overall life satisfaction. For instance, an increase in GDP per capita driven by longer working hours may not indicate an improvement in the quality of life if it comes at the expense of leisure time and well-being.
Shortcomings for comparing between Singapore and other countries
When comparing the standard of living between Singapore and other countries, several additional limitations must be considered. One key issue is differences in purchasing power. The cost of goods and services varies across countries, meaning that higher incomes in one country do not necessarily translate to greater purchasing power if living costs are also significantly higher. For example, while average salaries in Singapore are higher than in Malaysia, the cost of living in Singapore is also considerably greater. Thus, a direct comparison of GDP per capita without adjusting for purchasing power parity (PPP) may lead to misleading conclusions about relative living standards.
Another limitation is the impact of exchange rate fluctuations on GDP per capita comparisons. International comparisons typically require conversion into a common currency, often the US dollar. However, exchange rates are subject to fluctuations due to factors unrelated to economic performance, such as speculative currency movements or geopolitical events. For example, after Brexit, the British pound depreciated significantly against the US dollar, leading to a substantial decline in the UK's GDP per capita when expressed in USD. However, this drop did not necessarily reflect an actual decline in the standard of living for UK residents.
Additionally, the accuracy of data collection presents a challenge in cross-country comparisons. GDP figures and related economic data may not always be accurately measured, particularly in large economies with significant rural populations where informal employment and unregistered economic activities are prevalent. In countries with substantial underground economies, a significant portion of economic transactions may go unrecorded, leading to an underestimation of actual economic activity and living standards. Issues such as tax evasion and illicit transactions further contribute to discrepancies in reported data, making direct comparisons difficult.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while GDP growth, inflation, and unemployment statistics provide useful insights into economic performance, they have notable limitations in assessing changes in the standard of living within Singapore and in making comparisons with other countries. Factors such as income inequality, purchasing power differences, exchange rate volatility, and data accuracy must be considered to obtain a more comprehensive and accurate assessment of living standards. Alternative measures, such as median income levels, quality of life indices, and purchasing power parity adjustments, may provide a more holistic perspective on the well-being of a population.
🎓 The H2 Economics Exam Pack — Everything You Need to Score the A
Reading model essays is useful. Writing your own — with clarity, structure, and confidence — is how you get results.
At Economics at Tuitiongenius (ETG), we’ve helped thousands of students go beyond passive learning. As one of the most established providers of H2 economics tuition in Singapore, we focus on teaching students how to think, apply, and score — just like the top A Level performers.
🚀 One Bundle. Zero Guesswork. Maximum Impact.
With A Levels just around the corner, the ETG H2 Exam Pack gives you the full package — content mastery, writing techniques, and exam strategies — all in one place. No more jumping between crash courses.
📦 What You’ll Get:
✅ Micro & Macro Crashcourses — with lifetime on-demand access
✅ Essay & Case Study Bootcamps — 60+ A Level questions dissected and explained
✅ Skills Boosters + Personalised Feedback — fix your weak spots and sharpen your strengths
✅ Printed Resources Delivered — notes, summaries, model answers and more
✅ Taught by Mr Eugene Toh, one of Singapore’s most experienced economics tutors
💬 “This was the structure I didn’t even know I needed. Everything finally clicked.”
💡 Built for Students Who:
Struggled through J1 and want a reset
Are aiming for their first L3s or distinction
Need structured H2 economics tuition that focuses on results
If you’ve been looking for reliable economics tuition Singapore or an economics tuition centre that delivers real progress — this is it.
🔗 tuitiongenius.com/h2exampack
📲 WhatsApp us at 8168 3986 — and we’ll help you get started
Let’s make your A Level breakthrough happen — with ETG by your side.